“I feel one can say with some conviction that no man should willingly leave his home to fight, wound, maim or kill other men about whom he knows little and whom he certainly does not hate. When all men refuse to commit such follies the foundations of a true civilisation will have only just started to be laid.”
- Sam Sutcliffe, circa 1974 (extracted from his Memoir)
Showing posts with label chivalry. Show all posts
Showing posts with label chivalry. Show all posts

Sunday, 5 May 2019

Sussex, May, 1919: Brit POWs guarding German POWs… and Sam’s first post-war romance – with the little lady from Littlehampton – reaches the crunch moment: can his despite-it-all virginal virtue survive a roll in the haystack?

Sam’s Memoir(1) – paperback and e-book – and the e-excerpts from it are now available in their third and final editions with added Endnotes and, in the Memoir, added documentation.

For details of how to buy the Memoir or Gallipoli Somme & Arras 1918/POWetc mini-e-books click here plus see reader reviews here and here  and reviews from the Western Front Association and the Gallipoli Association hereFor AUDIO excerpts click Here  Join Foot Soldier Sam on Facebook Here

The war’s over at last – but Sam’s blog, Facebook page and tweets will continue until his Memoir concludes with the Centenary of the July 19, 1919, Peace parade in London…

All proceeds from all versions of Sam’s Memoir will always go to the British Red Cross – and the current running donations total as of May 1, 2019, is £4,178.05 (I can't update it in the Donations box below because the "edit" tool has vanished!).

Dear all

A hundred years ago this week, in the aftermath of the Armistice… Germany started to get the bad news from the Paris Peace Conference. Given no voice in the discussions, on May 7 their new Weimar government was granted its first official sight of some of the Versailles terms. In the previous days, they’d lost their Chinese colonies to Japan (to China’s chagrin – riots ensued as reported in last week’s blog), but now they learned of German East Africa’s re-assignment to Britain and France and German South West Africa’s transfer to South Africa. Four days later, after digesting, Germany protested. But only worse was to come…
    Meanwhile, Italian Prime Minister Orlando, concerned about any future reunion between Germany and Austria – the latter Italy’s invader foe during World War I – had negotiated in April to acquire the South Tyrol, taking in about 250,000 German speakers, Trieste, Trentino and Dalmatia. Then, when President Wilson blocked Italian acquisition of Fiume, on the Adriatic, Orlando stormed out… only to return in early May having gained nothing and lost out on his ambition to take the port of Smyrna (now Izmir) in western Turkey.
    Away from the conference table, Russia remained at war – albeit with itself. While the vestigial Allied forces up north near Archangel again beat off the Bolshevik Army (May 10), in the ‘Counteroffensive Of Eastern Front’ (April 22-July 19; definitely no definite article before the ‘Eastern’) phase of the civil war the Red Army’s southern group tried to surround their White opponents in Tatarstan (about 1,200 miles east of Moscow), but they got away to the east (May 6). Trying to build their strength out that way, the Bolshevik Government drafted 35,000 Central Asian Muslims (from May 7), but soon found them rebelling and joining the anti-Russian Basmachie fighters – Turks in Turkistan, particularly around Tashkent (2,100 miles southeast of Moscow; now in Uzbekistan).  
    In “the subcontinent”, Great Britain started a war on Afghanistan (May 6-August 8) following an Afghan incursion into India to take a town called Bagh at the western end of the Khyber Pass (May 3). British, Indian and Gurkha troops attempted to recover it on May 9 and failed, but came again and drove the Afghans back over the border (11)…

[Memoir background: my father, Lance Corporal Signaller Sam Sutcliffe from Edmonton, north London,16-year-old underage volunteer in September, 1914, fought at Gallipoli with the 2/1st Royal Fusiliers (Blogs September 20, 2015, to January 3, 2016), then on the Somme Front with his second outfit, the Kensingtons (Blogs May 15 to September 25, 2016)… until officialdom spotted his real age – 18, legally too young for the battlefield. They told him he could take a break from the fighting until he turned 19. He accepted, though with an enduring sense of guilt. December, 1916, saw him posted to Harrogate, Yorkshire, and re-allocated to the Essex Regiment Battalion (Blogs November 27, 2016, to November 11, 2017). During this interlude he suffered various illnesses while recovering from trench warfare’s privations. In December, probably, solo, he returned to France – reverting to Private on arrival, I don’t know why – and dogsbodied around Arras until mid-March when he ran into his own Essex 2/7th Battalion. They moved into the trenches near Fampoux just in time for the German Spring Offensive. A last stand by the Battalion on March 28, 1918, left 80 alive and “fit” out of the 520 who started the day – the 440 in between being dead, wounded or, like Sam, “missing” and, in his case, a POW (Blog March 25, 2018). For several months he wandered occupied France in randomly-assembled half-starved POW groups doing hard labour, before spending the summer in southern Germany and finally moving westwards to Lorraine – whence, the day after Armistice, his long trek towards the French Front began. He reached safety after tiptoeing through a German minefield (November 15 probably). Then began his recovery from chronic near-starvation – and a brief emotional breakdown – until, finally, on December 10, 1918, he returned to England and another few days in hospital before reuniting with parents and siblings, especially brother Ted, home on a week’s leave but suffering badly from gas damage. Civilian life offered Sam a warm welcome… until, in February, 1919, the Army called him back - though only to a “Dad’s Army” unit. Meaning, at first, a few weeks de facto holiday in Brighton. But then, something completely different… through the spring, Sam and others ex-POWs guard German POWs at a camp in Sussex, while making various attempts to get back to “normal” life…]

FOOTSOLDIERSAM SPEAKS
April-May, 1919, Sussex: Sam continues with his final Army job, in a squad of fellow ex-POWs guarding German war prisoners still detained at a run-down near-stately home in the village of East Preston, five miles southeast of Arundel. Transferred to Home Guard forerunner, the Royal Defence Corps, he’s emerged from a short-lived lust for revenge and come to enjoy fraternising with (most of) the enemy – the two lots of POWs found they had quite a bit in common as fellow veterans of WW1 attritional front-line trench warfare… 
    But Sam still had business unconcluded – and mutually frustrating – with the sophisticated(?) young woman he’d been seeing in Littlehampton (a two-and-a-half-mile walk across the fields from East Preston). Thus far the virginity he’d not surrendered throughout the war, despite it all, remained intact…

‘For a brief, extremely enjoyable period, I continued to take my dozen or so Jerries along to the river to push those large lumps of chalk about(2); those we had placed in position earlier had already combined into a smooth, strong riverbank which would last for many years.
     I still walked out once or twice a week with my formerly prim, arm-swinging bird(3), but I sensed that my slow rate of progress towards something more intimate made her impatient – especially on one fine, warm summer’s evening, when she led me to the rear of a haystack where we rested among the sweet-smelling stuff, and she encouraged me to explore so far uncharted areas by telling me about her wartime goings-on.
     I learned that a coloured American soldier(4), one of many billeted in the district during the final months, had lived in her home and become very much one of the family – to such an extent that, as an accepted part of household routine, each morning he took a cup of tea up to my girlfriend in her bedroom. He stayed talking to her while she drank it and so subtly extended the length of his visits that no one noticed when a quarter of an hour, or sometimes even more, passed before he joined the others at breakfast.
     Eventually, there came a time for him to join her between the sheets. She enjoyed this morning ceremony, and tried to get me at it – even with hay for a bed and the risk of the farmer arriving at an interesting, if awkward moment.
     Difficult to put my finger on the real reason for my reluctance to co-operate… Being number two to the Alabamy bloke was one thing anti, a black man in bed; a clash of some sort there. But the teachings of my pre-war mentor, Mr Frusher(5), the vicar, piano teacher and Scoutmaster, still held much influence within me; never take advantage of a woman’s natural urge to have the egg fertilised, he would say… I also felt chagrin about being such a rotten judge, believing that what my eyes saw was necessarily the truth. The pretty little hat, the waisted, calf-length, Navy-blue coat, the white gloves the dainty step, and that swinging arm. Demure propriety personified…
     At the time, without giving too much thought to any of these matters, I decided to quit. That there might have been a piccaninny in the making may also have occurred to me. I don’t rightly remember.’
(2) See last week’s blog for the details of the work detail in the Arun valley below handsome Arundel Castle.
(3) See Blog April 14 for Sam’s gradual “courting” of the “arm-swinging bird” or the Littlehampton Lady as I dubbed her: ‘…she walked, her bearing regal, she looked neither right nor left. Her right arm swung sort of diagonally, finishing behind her back. Her left hand held a large handbag carried with arm fully extended and rigid. A Captain maybe could make an advance of some kind, or even a Lieutenant, but me, no. Till late one afternoon…’ – she stopped this strange ritual of walking ahead of Sam (she must have spotted him entering the town across the fields and timed her walk precisely several weekends in a row, it seems), turned around and invited him to walk with her. After some platonic “walking out” – literally, to country inns – she evidently decided to hurry him along a bit by saying ‘she enjoyed my company best when I’d got a couple of whiskies under my belt’.
(4) As Sam’s son, I remain somewhat embarrassed about this passage because of the language he uses – “coloured” and (further on) “piccaninny” now deemed racist diction – and the degree of racism he recalls feeling in the course of this episode back when he was 20. As his editor, I decided not to cut or remove these paragraphs because, like everything else about his Memoir, it was personally honest and true to his times. “Times” plural, because a) you can see here how the old Sam – in his 70s during the ’70s when he was writing – was uneasy about his younger self’s attitudes while candidly recording them, but b) in ’70s Britain, neither “coloured” nor “piccaninny” had become subject to the linguistic shifts which, in the natural course of cultural evolution, constantly move the meanings and implications of words around so that, for instance, some, like these two, become signifiers of racism. 
(5) Mr Frusher, his de facto mentor in Edmonton when he was aged about 10 to 16, had made Sam a prude or a gentleman, according to taste, with his emphasis on the male responsibility to rebuff female desires until the appropriate time – namely, after marriage. He called it “chivalry”. Sam’s Littlehampton Lady obviously thought his restraint worse than unnecessary. And young Sam no doubt persuaded himself that it was all down to rather noble virtue… so that he could overlook his shyness and fear in relationships with women. Fortunately, I can report that he got over this impediment soon after the war, thought rather later than the end of his Memoir; he told me how another bold girl visited him when he was bed-ridden with a cold, climbed in with him and gave him an experience he deemed well worth repeating quite often thereafter.

All the best– FSS

Next week: Sam, writing in 1972-6, didn’t foresee that I might adapt his Memoir into a weekly blog, so he didn’t write enough to about certain periods to spread evenly across the months – and May to late June is one such thin spell. So before returning to his demob and the crescendo of the grand Peace parade on July 19, I’m going to run a highlights reel, so to speak: a three-part Retro sequence from his north London childhood and teens covering The Making Of A Tommy, followed by four long collections of excerpts on the key moments of his three great campaigns/battles, Gallipoli, the Somme, the Spring Offensive and one on his POW months through to Armistice and freedom.

(1) In his 70s, Sam Sutcliffe wrote Nobody Of Any Importance, a Memoir of his life from childhood through Gallipoli, the Somme, Arras 1918 and eight months as a POW to the 1919 Peace parade.

Sunday, 18 June 2017

The Making Of Foot Soldier Sam, 1903-1914 – from poor people’s “tin” churches to Vicar /choirmaster/mentor Mr Frusher bringing Sam the thrill of music…

For details of how to buy Sams full Memoir* in paperback or e-book & excerpted Gallipoli & Somme episode mini-e-books & reader reviews see right-hand column
All proceeds to the British Red Cross
For AUDIO excerpts click Here  Join Foot Soldier Sam on Facebook Here


Dear all

A hundred years ago this week… On the Western Front, bloody skirmishing continued in the Battle Of Messines’ aftermath, with the usual sense of to and fro rather than decisive advantage accruing to either side. The British Army lost ground on Infantry Hill (June 18; they’d taken it on the 14th), then recovered it again (20). But they did advance a little outside Arras and Lens (19 and 24). Similarly, the French made a little progress in Champagne between Mont Cornillet and Mont Blond (18), but lost out to the German Army near Vauxaillon on the Chemin Des Dames (20) only regain it the next day… while getting driven back on the Chemin southeast of Filain.
    In the most substantial conflict of the moment, the Battle Of Mount Ortigara (June 10-25), the Italian Army continued to look like beating the Austrians – having taken the summit on the first day – by taking more ground there, doing likewise on the Asiago Plateau below (both 19) and also advancing further east on the Carnia front at Piccolo Lagaznoi (20).
    At sea, the sinking of P&O liner SS Mongolia 50 miles off Bombay (June 23; 23 lost) highlighted the effect of German minelayers like SMS Wolf, credited with sinking 35 merchant vessels and two warships

[Memoir background: my father, Lance Corporal Sam Sutcliffe from Edmonton, north London, under-age 2/1st Royal Fusiliers volunteer and Gallipoli veteran [Blogs September 20, 2015, to January 3, 2016], had fought on the Somme Front with his second outfit the Kensingtons (Blogs May 15 to September 25, 2016)… until officialdom spotted his age – 18 on July 6, 1916, legally too young for the battlefield – and told him he could take a break from the fighting until he was 19. He did so, though with an enduring sense of guilt. By December, 1916, he ended up posted to Harrogate, Yorkshire, and re-allocated again, this time to the Essex Regiment 2/7th Battalion, along with a bunch of other under-age Tommies training/marking time – and in Sam’s case dicing with meningitis and other battle-fatigue enhanced ailments – until such time as they severally became eligible for the trenches once more… Well, my father didn’t write enough about his year “off” in England to cover 1917 in weekly chunks (I can hardly blame him; writing his Memoir in the 1970s he wasn’t really thinking about blog requirements). So for now the blog continues with themed childhood and teens material – his formative years – under the title The Making Of FootSoldierSam.]

FOOTSOLDIERSAM SPEAKS
Last week, The Making Of Foot Soldier Sam covered his schooldays and his gradual discovery of his own talents, despite relentlessly daunting comparisons with his older brother Ted’s sparky brilliance. So, although he started out just striving for invisibility, by the time he had to leave at 14 – like Ted two years earlier, because of his family’s poverty – he had become “top boy”, creating and presenting shows and writing a book on African history.
    Now these excerpts illustrate his relationship with the church – which is to say various churches. He doesn’t seem to have been a particularly “religious” child/young man in the theological sense and barely mentions any kind of deity throughout the Memoir. But, around a basic faith, he drew much observed knowledge of human life and his own moral standards from involvement in church activities.
    The children (four of them then, Ciss, Ted, Sam and Sidney); Alf arrived in 1903) had attended a church in Tottenham when they first came down from Manchester to London, and from wealth to poverty, in 1902. But they had to start again when they moved to Edmonton a year or so later, when Sam was 5 or 6 – he was born on July 6, 1898. For Sam this place turned out to be about characters – and cake. (NB: my father wrote the early chapters in the third person, calling himself “the boy” and then “Tommy”, while he temporarily aliased Ted as “George”.)

‘Not long after the family’s arrival in this growing suburb, it had occurred to mother that church attendance would be good for the children. She probably would not have time for it herself and father would not want to do anything of that sort because the religion to which he had been slightly attached in Manchester was Unitarianism and there was no branch of that somewhat obscure sect nearby. So sister [Ciss, 10 by then] was given the job of seeking out a suitable place…
     Somebody told her about a small church half a mile along the road – a “tin church”, they called it. She set off one Sunday with the other children and found it standing back from the main road, surrounded by rough grass. They were accepted immediately and, each according to their age, given a place in a Sunday school class.
     The tin church had a small hall attached with, at one end, a platform bearing a small organ, its pipes brightly painted, and a couple of tables at which sat the people who were going to conduct the service. To the side of the platform stood two tall, anthracite stoves of roughcast metal, their chimneys poking out through the roof. With them alight, the place warmed up comfortably. The stoker was a Mrs Pavitt – small, thin, wispy grey hair, toothless, pale blue eyes, a sort of smile from time to time. She seldom spoke, but worked very hard to keep this place warm and clean even though the odd shilling or two would be all that this poor community could afford to pay her.
     At the organ for a rousing hymn, a tall, young man called Cyril Smith perched on a stool, his rather lank hair flopping down over his forehead – but a nice face with a good smile. The preacher would read aloud a verse of Rally Round The Banner or some similar lively, lilting, marching sort of hymn, then off Cyril would swing and the congregation heartily followed, singing various parts to the best of their ability. Turning the pages of the sheet music for him, if necessary, and keeping close to him, was his girlfriend… I suppose you would call her. Marjorie Peters had blue eyes, bulging somewhat, a broad nose, very prominent, front top teeth, a healthy colour in her cheeks and as tall as Cyril. A well-matched pair. She too played the organ and socked out those bracing hymns.
     Two men took charge of the service for the whole congregation. Two very different types. Mr Reardon, rather flat of foot, average height, a good head of hair and a droopy moustache, much given to smiling. When he preached a sermon or composed a prayer there was gaiety to it, happiness, and he played a very sweet euphonium when they went out to sing their hymns in the street. Mr Reardon worked as an insurance agent, collecting local people’s pennies and halfpennies door to door.
     His opposite number, Gillette, had a deep bass voice, splendidly underpinning the hymns… When they sang, Gillette’s face was white, but his eyes burned. Young, with a blue chin and a big Adam’s apple, when he preached it was with all the depths of sincerity he could muster. His strong speaking voice was just the vehicle to transport the brimstone and fire which would be slopped over the people should they stray from the narrow, straight path. Yet, while he stood on that small platform, his eyes would stray to follow Marjorie Peters’s every movement, and when he sang solos to her organ accompaniment his loud voice became harsh with emotion, his face more lugubrious every time he looked her way.
     The children in the choir and congregation noticed every detail. “Cor, look at his dial now!” they’d mutter. They felt that his unrequited love for her was a little local tragedy in which they were all, to some extent, concerned… All this lent a little colour to those parts of the service which might otherwise have seemed dull.
     On Sunday afternoons the children went to Sunday school and sat at benches arranged in groups around the teacher’s chair. Tommy’s group had a Mr Blackhead, a little man, ashen of face, a bluish, shaved-but-still-visible beard, black, wavy hair, small, dark eyes, 45 perhaps. Certainly he wasn’t an open-air type and one could assume that he worked in a foundry…  If you happened to sit near him his sourish breath would come floating over… His class was useful in that it helped to pass the time…
     One sunny Sunday evening, the smiling and happy Reardon stood on the platform, euphonium under arm, and called upon the brothers to sally forth into the streets and take the message to the people. With Cyril and Marjorie carrying a small harmonium between them, the whole congregation set off. In a side street they formed a circle, the harmonium in the middle. All had their hymn books with them and, led by the two instruments, they sang heartily. “Happy day, happy day, when Jesus washed my sins away/He taught me how to watch and pray.” If the little bag passed around at one of these street meetings realised two or three shillings, that would be a very good evening.
     Over the year or so during which the children attended that chapel, they put the odd ha’pennies and pennies they’d saved into the annual outing fund — a trip to the sea, the crowning day of the year for the children. When it arrived, their excitement was intense. The Sunday-school teachers took them to the nearest railway station where they boarded a specially chartered train. The cost per head must have been very small.
     Tommy paid no attention to the name of their destination, but the thing he did remember was the tea. Lots of women bustling about ushered them into a big hall, hustling them towards trestle tables. Enamel mugs full of lovely tea. Bread and butter. Butter! What a treat. And cake. Plenty of cake. The cake did smell lovely, it really thrilled Tommy.’

Despite that pleasant interlude, after a few months, Sam/”Tommy” and siblings found they had to change their place of worship again – reaping accidental benefits for their beleaguered father:

‘After all that, mother suddenly discovered they had gone to the wrong church! Had sister taken them just a little further along and to the right side of the main road they would have found a Church of England. Another tin church – corrugated iron, that is.
     As mother reminded them, they had been christened into the C of E** shortly after their arrival in London. At that time a lady had called and given them some little silvery sweets which they had relished. She chatted with mother, told her she was a visitor from a nearby church, and learned of the family’s circumstances. So she sent along some very useful things: a sack of coal and a few items of food.
     Mother could do no less than take the children along to that church and have them christened…  they had joined the C of E fold and now the discovery of the correct tin church began a better and very interesting phase in the life of the family.
     This was a mission church.*** A large church in the wealthy part of the West End of London had set aside a fund to establish a mission among the poor people living in these semi-developed outer-London suburbs. There was no real hint of snobbery or class in this. The clergyman received a very small salary.
     He turned out to be a very likeable man. Glanfield Rowe was his name… As was the custom, soon after the children joined his congregation, he visited their home. He met mother and later father also. Mr Rowe being a reasonably well educated man, father felt that here was somebody to whom he could talk freely.
     The two met on several occasions, on one of which father was persuaded to change his faith and be baptised into the Church of England… The collapse of the family business in Manchester had dealt a severe blow to father. Ever since, he had become rather timid and fearful. But his association with the rector in this small church seemed to stiffen his morale a bit. He got a slightly better job as an under-manager in the shipping firm for which he was working and this meant a small rise in salary.’
** Records for the parish of St. Olave, Woodberry Down, Middlesex, show four children baptised on September 17, 1902: Dorothy (“Ciss”), Philip Broughton (“Ted”), Charles Samuel, and Frank Sidney.
*** The mission church movement within London began about 1880; maybe the “tin church” was what one web source describes as the “iron room” put up in 1904 on the northern side of Malden Road, Edmonton, but there seem to have been several others in the district.

Here, looking back from his 70s when he wrote the Memoir, Sam notes how church society eased some of poverty’s oppressions – but not all by any means:

‘…many did survive on the tiniest of incomes, like Tommy’s family, keeping at least an outward appearance of what was called respectability. They frequently suffered deprivations in their home. But even in those circumstances they could still find energy and time to do a little to help others, as with church work. But the toll on nerves, the irritation, the bitterness, the feeling of instability and fear of even worse overtaking them often blighted the lives of people who were doing their best to keep things going under difficult circumstances. And of course the children often suffered the lash of the tongue or the slap of the hand, not always deserved.’

Still, “Tommy”/Sam’s father felt uplifted by the contribution he could make, with Glanfield Rowe’s encouragement:

‘In due course, Mr Rowe persuaded father and, to some extent, mother to play a more active part in church events. Father became secretary of the men’s club – its purpose to provide an hour or two’s friendly entertainment to the members of the congregation.
     The parson’s ambitions soared and he organised a committee to draw up the plans for a garden fete. One of the more wealthy local residents was persuaded to permit the use of his fairly extensive grounds. Of course, the committee took several months to organise the day. Various people were voted into taking care of specific tasks. Father was voted treasurer. Mother undertook to be in charge of the food and drink side. From its original small concept onwards, it had begun to grow into quite a large affair.
     Tommy and his brother were to take their turn selling ice cream – made by a local shopkeeper – in cornets and wafers. With no bulk manufacturer then, each trader made his own in a small machine and supplied it in cylinders… They set them up on a stand constructed by a carpenter member of the congregation.
     The aim was to raise as much money as possible for a fund dedicated to building a new church hall. Since this was a mission church, for every £100 raised the mother church would certainly contribute at least another £100. Everybody worked to that end. The parishioners were poor, but it looked as though the women had been working very hard to make clothes to wear on the day, sewing their own dresses and decorating hats… Their appearance on the day did them credit. The men couldn’t afford new suits, but those they had were clean, the trousers pressed, and they all looked fine. A feeling of brotherhood and endeavour prevailed.

You see here the beginnings of a change in the life of the family. Formerly prosperous and then down to the depths of poverty and despair, they were now getting integrated into a community at times. The parents became known by the people in that district and, although very poor, seemed the better for it – especially father, through his part in the church men’s club.
     Soon after the fete, the new church hall was built and the club had the good fortune to be given the use of a large room with a full-size billiard table and equipment for other games. The wives provided light refreshments and Tommy remembered his mother sewing the heavy leather cloth together for the cover to spread over the billiard table at close of play. A nice, social atmosphere developed and when the boy was allowed into the club room for a few moments, he noticed the difference in his father. That normally quiet, sometimes morose man became quite affable among other men, smiling, chatting away in a manner which Tommy had thought impossible.
     … mother and father took part in more social events there. They organised dances – the music, the catering. They would plague the local shopkeepers for assistance, donations in kind. Tea, sugar, anything of that sort, lemonade, ice cream — generally members of the congregation, of course, the shopkeepers must have suffered a sort of sweet blackmail at times to get them to part with stock they could hardly afford to give away. But commerce and religion were closely linked; the tradesmen did tend to join the church they thought would bring them the most customers.
     The dances gave amateur musicians the chance to show their skill. At first, the band consisted of violins, mandolins, a cello, a bass, kettle and bass drums. They gave a swing to it. Old-time dances. Valetas and other waltzes. Humble though the company, a mantle of great decorum, restraint and respectability descended on them when they took to the floor, partly because they had a professional MC. As was the custom, dressed in tails, with a large buttonhole and white gloves, he occupied the centre of the dance floor and took strict control. During each dance, he would take a lady round and demonstrate the steps, beating time, and talking to each couple in turn, ensuring that they followed his instruction.
     The price of admission included the purchase of a dance card for each lady, a booklet really, printed on stiff board with a pencil attached on a silky cord. When approached for a dance, the lady would note the name of the applicant against the numbered dance of her choice.
     You couldn’t be glum on such occasions, each helping as much as he could. They were all learning to conduct themselves in a nice, happy way with their fellows, the ordinary poor people and those few with a little more money joining together…’

Happy as he was at the tin church, the lad was to undertake one further ecclesiastical transfer. It came about through Mr Frusher, already his Scoutmaster. “Tommy”/Sam must have been nine or ten by then, because the Scouts didn’t establish themselves as a national organisation until May, 1908, two years after Baden Powell’s “Brownsea experiment”. This change was chiefly significant for Sam because it opened the door to his lifelong delight in playing piano and in music generally:

‘Suddenly a change occurred for Tommy. In charge of the Scout Troop was a cultured man, whose name I’ve mentioned in passing – Mr Frusher, who was also the vicar, the organist and choirmaster at the parish church. He had private means, being a member of the family which owned and controlled the three local newspapers (he took no active part in the business, concerning himself with the church and the Scout movement). He approached Tommy at one of the Scout gatherings and said, “I’d like you to join the church choir. Ask your parents if they will be agreeable. It will mean you changing your church.” The full C of E church – as opposed to their familiar “tin” mission – was a mile and a half further away from Tommy’s house****. But the parents agreed to the move.
     Tommy joined the choir having only just passed the vocal test, which proved pretty strict… Mr Frusher’s eventual approval surprised him – as did the small payments to be had from singing with the choir. Four times a year the Sunday collection would be shared among the members — a fair amount, for the congregation filled the building.
     The vicar, an MA, was a Cambridge graduate and a fellow of Trinity College, the Royal Academy of Music, and the Royal College of Organists too…  with his dome of a head, his powerful voice and perfect diction, he had the gift of making people believe that all was well in this best of all worlds; after his sermons, they would leave the church feeling secure, strong, fortified, ready to meet the trials of the coming week…
     [For choir practice] at the very large organ, controlling all the musical proceedings from the height of his stool, sat Mr Frusher, whom Tommy liked and respected so well. A mirror above the keyboards gave him a complete view of the choir and the younger members were well aware of that so no misbehaviour ever occurred during the service.
     The usual Sunday evening saw this grand church, almost a cathedral, completely filled with people and everybody enjoying the singing. None more heartily, I fear, than Figgy Avverdate — extremely tall, ragged clothes, a pot hat on the back of his head, a face of extreme ugliness with bloodshot, bulging eyes, beetling brows and a high forehead, a fattened nose, his mouth surly when closed and displaying blackened fangs when open, a dirty rag round his long, scrawny neck, a discarded long, black gent’s morning coat worn and torn, trousers of indescribable filth, and on his feet big, club-soled boots, the toes cut away to reveal corny toes and bunions. On the street, he would usually stand leaning against a wall, a figure of dread to all children.
     So a new world opened up: music. Tommy’s training was strict and very detailed and he felt his life becoming quite full… Mr Frusher had a big house, much too big you might say for one man and his housekeeper – she and her family occupied the basement. But the whole place was well used. He had two music rooms, one at the front on the ground floor, the other on the first floor, and each contained a Bechstein piano. He used the breakfast room, at the rear on the ground floor, for choir or Scouts meetings and a large back room on the second floor for church committee meetings and the Sunday afternoon class.
     Picture Mr Frusher of medium height, well-built, wearing a beard, pointed, and the then fashionable pince-nez. Most days he wore a frock coat with a silk hat and striped trousers. Tommy used to love looking at the boots he wore; without toecaps, of fine soft leather, kept in good condition by his housekeeper. He was one of those cold-bath-in-the-morning men. He would sometimes describe with relish how he had broken the ice. The water was poured out the night before into his hip bath in his bedroom where there was no heating (it was not customary except in case of sickness). His working day, training people to play the piano, started at 9.30am and went through to maybe 6pm. Comfortably off, he varied his terms according to each pupil’s financial position.
     Around that time, Tommy heard how this good man had been engaged to be married some years previously, but the girl died of consumption. He had been very broken up and went to live in Switzerland. Some regarded this as a selfish thing. But there was the possibility of him having contracted this highly contagious disease and Switzerland was the recognised place for curing, or at least alleviating, the condition. He came back to this life and devoted all his waking hours to church, music and the Scouts. Many boys were the better for these activities and the older ones maintained contact with him even if they went abroad.
     All that left two evenings vacant for Tommy, but before long he joined the vicar’s class to learn music. The children could afford to buy only one type of instrument, the flageolet, big brother of the tin whistle. The vicar gave them sheets of music in staff notation and Tommy had no difficulty in playing the tunes as soon as he mastered the simple technique of covering half the hole to play the half-note. The two- and three-part arrangements provided by Mr Frusher sounded very good — rather like the recorders children play nowadays.’
**** All Saints, on Church Street, Edmonton, still occupies the site of a church built in the early 12th century and a few fragments of the Norman original remain in the west wall.

Aside from the choir repertoire and the flageolet tunes, “Tommy”/Sam had already developed a liking for the pop music of the day through the church dances and the cylinders of music hall songs one of the family’s lodgers used to play on his phonograph – Sam recalled ‘… When Father Painted The Parlour, along with other more sentimental numbers’ and ‘the little group sitting round listening, the comfort and companionship of the room’. And he was about to develop his natural gift via setting himself a very tricky challenge:

‘At home, Tommy’s parents made an important addition to the furniture in the front room – the parlour, as they called it. A friend of Tommy’s sister told her that, her father having died and her mother being compelled to let half of the house, an old piano had to go. It was completely out of tune and very old, but when it was mentioned to mother she agreed to have it. She paid only a few shillings, just for carriage. The piano looked extraordinary; very tall – almost three times the height of modern pianos – with ornamental woodwork, candlesticks and red silk curtains covering the front part of it above the old, yellowed keys.
     Tommy, already much interested in music, made a wild promise to tune it. He felt sure he could do it by ear. He’d seen a man in the local piano shop doing it: the tool, the “key”, he used on the screw at the top of each string, turning it this way and that until it sounded right. Tommy discussed it with his friends and one young man said that, if Tommy took an impression of the shape of the screw at the top of each string, at his place of work he could make a tool to fit.
     Tommy mentioned his intention to Mr Frusher. A rather derisive smile greeted the proposition, but he gave Tommy a tuning fork for A. With this to guide him, he used the key to get the middle note right and the rest followed from that. The complete job took a long time. Day after day, in his spare moments he’d be sitting there tapping away on the keys and turning the screws until his ear told him it was as near as he would get. The deep bass remained questionable, the ear alone could not get that correct. But he had the beginnings of a piano. Good enough to play with one finger.
     When he told Mr Frusher he’d about finished the job, curiosity overcame the choirmaster and he had to call round and see it. Although, when he played a few bars on this thing, his face betrayed a degree of pain, still he complimented the lad on what he’d done and said, “If you like, I’ll give you a few lessons. You already know something of music. I’ll teach you the scales and arpeggios and so forth and we’ll see how you get on.”
     Thereafter, Tommy took a half hour’s lesson every week — free, for Tommy’s parents couldn’t afford to pay, of course – all scales as promised, apart from the odd small practice piece. Scales of every key and major harmonic or melodic minor. Mr Frusher’s lessons concentrated on getting the fingers supple, in the correct position, covering the correct notes. Tommy would faithfully carry out the practice as directed by the master and then, at the end of each session, he would treat himself to a little informal tinkering about on the keys, perhaps working out a few bars of a popular tune, a music-hall ditty.
     At school, generally he was quite happy. But soon his piano studies gave him a chance for more enjoyment and to enhance his standing among his classmates — all because of the scholarly teacher’s willingness to encourage any special talent he might find among the boys. When he heard about Tommy taking lessons from Mr Frusher, he had the school piano wheeled right through from the hall into the classroom, sat Tommy down, fixed his music up on the rest, and said, “Right, well, play”. And he did. A popular piece of the day called Blake’s March and, after that, one of the simple songs he had learnt. For his age he played very well. The class felt somehow relaxed, a relief from pressure, and Tommy’s performance became a regular feature of Friday afternoons for several weeks in succession.’

“Tommy”/Sam’s busy programme of Scouts, choir, music lessons and school carried him happily through from 10 to 14, 1908-12. Then he had to leave school for lack of cash, as recounted in last week’s blog. Although, about the time he went out to work he even had to leave the choir because his voice broke, in one area of life he actually came more firmly under Mr Frusher’s mentorship, specifically his teaching of the bold yet puritanical sexual morality which was to guide the lad throughout the war:

‘A subtle change occurred in Mr Frusher’s treatment of these seniors, both as Scouts and members of his church. Consultation with them about the organisation of events and outings became his new approach where, previously, he had taken charge. Those who had, before their voices broke, served as choirboys under him and attended Sunday school, he now invited to separate meetings. Like the first-aid classes, these took place at his house. Usually, they took the form of a discussion, on Biblical subjects mostly, chaired by the Governor [the lads’ nickname for Frusher]. He did not repeat Sunday school’s childish views of the book’s teaching and stories, instead suggesting more earthy explanations.
     On these occasions, Mr Frusher even led discussions of men-women relationships. Discouraging romantic notions without deriding them, the elderly, bachelor teacher continued where the school lessons in anatomy and physiology left off. “Frankness in these matters kills morbid curiosity,” he would say. He explained the sex organs – particularly the female genital parts always omitted from the school’s anatomical charts.
     In a sensible way, he described the feelings contact between the sexes could arouse, the actions and the results that would follow: the girls in trouble, the unwanted babies; the worry, regret, fear; the difficulties which beset a young man who has fathered a bastard. He drew this picture so impressively the lads were never likely to forget. In fact, he constantly impressed upon them that sexual intercourse before marriage was wrong, a crime, it must never even be considered, let alone indulged in.
     He instructed them about another aspect of sexual development too: masturbation. He told them what a habit it could develop into, assumed they had never done it – correctly in most cases, thought Tommy – and assured them that if they never started they would never be bothered by the habit. What he used to call “night losses” – about which most young men know something – would, he believed, have an ill effect on a lad. But they could be averted, he said, if you didn’t sleep on your back. This could be achieved, he recommended, by tying a cotton reel or bobbin round your waist and placing the uncomfortable object against the spine.
     But, beyond such practical matters, he wished the lads to grow up as what he called “gentlemen”. The girl being so constituted that marriage and child-bearing were the most important things in her life, she would generally submit to a man’s desires – after a certain amount of caressing had taken place – in spite of any advice she may have received. Mr Frusher’s conclusion: the man – stronger, physically and mentally – had a bounden duty to accept responsibility and ensure that nothing occurred, when the girl was in his care, which he could not freely reveal to her parents. The final word had a memorable simplicity to it: chivalry.
     Coupled with lessons in physiology and home nursing, both part of advanced training for all Boy Scouts, this early debunking of the sham romanticism so prevalent in those days did help the boys. Furthermore, the Scout Code they had sworn to included the words “To be pure in thought and word and deed”******; sticking to it became a settled part of their life and conduct. Tommy remembered all these things in the company of the girls with whom he occasionally formed friendships. Some may have thought him reticent or slow, but all realised that, at any rate, he was safe… ’
****** The tenth article of Scout Law, added in the 1911 fourth edition of Baden-Powell’s Scouting For Boys.

All the best – FSS

Next week: The making of Foot Soldier Sam, 1910-14 – the Boy Scout ideal and the wider world; the family takes to the outdoor recreational life on the edge of London as fortunes take an upturn; a would-be night’s camping in the woods with his pal Joe Sheahan that goes all Blair Witch Project in a daft way; and Sam’s Big Fight against the School Bully…

* In his 70s, Sam Sutcliffe wrote Nobody Of Any Importance, a Memoir of his life from childhood through Gallipoli, the Somme, Arras 1918 and eight months as a POW to the 1919 Peace parade.